B1G Returns: Starters Back in 2012

Returning starters is one of the first things I look for each off season as I begin to take a look at Iowa’s upcoming schedule.

There isn’t a guaranteed correlation between a team’s upcoming success or lack there of related to returning starters, but more often than not it can prove to be a fairly reliable litmus test.

According to Phil Steele, Iowa returned the second fewest starters of any team in the FBS last year, a stat I cited several times throughout the season. The team was inconsistent throughout the season, which fits the profile of a team playing a lot of new faces.

The 2011 Wisconsin team overcame this stat, as they were 113 of 120 on Steele’s list, but with one huge asterisk. Steele’s numbers were published prior to Russell Wilson’s transfer to the Badgers. Had that not happened, I am convinced Wisconsin would have been more in the line for 7 or 8 wins in 2011 compared to what they wound up being, which was the Big Ten champion.

In 2011, Michigan was #2 in the nation in returning starters and they made it back to a BCS Bowl game. Purdue was 13th in the nation and they were +3 in wins over their 2010 total. Penn State was 39th and they were +2 in wins. Nebraska was 109th and they were -1. Ohio State was 90th and won six games after being in the BCS the year before.

Not all returning starters are equal and having your starting quarterback coming back is typically a boost to the program.

Here is what Steele has put together for this year as it relates to the Big Ten, with the FBS rank represented by the number on the far left, out of 123 schools.

The columns from left to right: National rank for returning starters, the school, offensive starters returning, defensive starters returning, kicking specialists returning and the total number of starters returning. The asterisk by a school’s offensive number indicates their quarterback is returning.

You can see Steele’s returning starter data for all FBS teams at this link

Indiana had a decent number of returning starters in 2011 yet it did not translate into a boost. This year, they return even more after playing so many young players in a coaching transition season. They also return QB Tre Roberson, who was a freshman last year and played well…at least he played well against Iowa. 17 position starters back? That’s a very, very high number and look for Indiana to be +3 or more in wins this year over their one win from last year.

Ohio State is next on the list and should also be +2 or more in the win column despite being ineligible for a bowl game in 2011. They found a quarterback in Braxton Miller and he should improve a great deal playing in Urban Meyer’s system.

Michigan ranks high in this compilation once again, but lower than they have in a few years. They have some defensive line losses that will challenge that side of the ball but they are in good hands with Greg Mattison as the DC. Denard Robinson is back for one more year on offense and Maize and Blue fans hope he will improve as a passer. They won 11 games last year, 10 in the regular season but I am not sure they will match that. I haven’t taken a serious look at their schedule just yet.

Nebraska’s biggest opportunity for growth resides on the defensive side of the ball, where they were a disappointment last season. At this point, I wouldn’t pick them to win more than their nine from one year ago because of their one dimensional quarterback. Then again, Rex Burkhead is back for them at running back and he was a beast in 2011. Plus, their schedule is very favorable, so that factor may offset everything else. It’s them and Michigan for the division title in my opinion and they host the Wolverines.

Purdue brings back the third highest total of returning position starters of any team in the league. They won six in the regular season last year and could do better than that this year.

Illinois is in the midst of a coaching change and that program is a huge question mark; the started last year 6-0 and finished 0-7. Nathan Scheelhaase is an exciting quarterback and the Illini have some good young RB’s in the stable, but they struggled late on defense and lost more key players.

Michigan State is tied with Wisconsin for the fewest returning offensive starters as well as losing some huge (literally) players on the defensive side of the ball. Kirk Cousins is gone and replacing him will be a big challenge. The Spartans have won 11 games in each of the last two seasons, but I see them -3 or more this season in the win column.

Penn State is tied for the fewest returning position starters. Yes, they return two starting quarterbacks but neither is all that great. They won 9 last year and I don’t see them getting there in 2012.

Wisconsin returns 10 starters, four on offense and lost the best football transfer in the history of NCAA football, arguably. As my friend Steve Deace likes to say, you can’t hide your quarterback in college football and Wisconsin is going to have issues at this position. A running game is a quarterback’s best friend and Wisconsin always has that, however they will not approach last year’s win totals.

As for Iowa, they are in the lower 25% in the nation in returning starters for the second year in a row. They lost their leading rusher, their all time leading receiver and three of their best four defensive linemen with the fourth recovering from a late season ACL injury.

I think Iowa’s 2011 win total of 7 games is in the range for what Iowa will accomplish in 2012.

What are your thoughts?

  • Larry Flint

    Michigan State returns too much talent on D to dive too far down.  Their D, when it was executing, was very impressive.  I look for MSU to ride their D and their running game to have a pretty good season.

    Also, word out of Nebraska is that Martinez has really made some nice strides.  When you look at the Husker passing numbers in Big 10 play, you quickly realize that they weren’t quite as 1-dimensional on O as many think.  Furthermore, the Huskers were really, really young at WR … and that group has an opportunity to truly make huge strides.  As much as I don’t like the Huskers, they will be poised to make a bit more noise in their second season in the conference.

    • jondmiller

      The best thing Nebraska has going for it this year, IMO, is that Burkhead is back and their schedule.  Their schedule is favorable for equalling last year’s win total without much consternation.  

      • IowaHusker79

        Still would like to know just how you think Nebraska’s schedule is favorable. I realize Wisconsin is without Wilson and the Huskers get Michigan and Penn State in Lincoln, but they still must play Michigan State, Ohio State, Iowa and UCLA all on the road. A favorable schedule would have them playing Illinois, Indiana and Purdue. In my opinion, the Huskers have one of the more difficult schedules in the Big Ten. Would like to get your opinion on this.   

        • IowaHusker79

          I forgot about Wisconsin. They come to Lincoln but they are still Wisconsin, a tough team to beat. 

    • IowaHusker79

      You, my friend, have done your homework. As a Husker fan I can tell you that Martinez looks like a totally different quarterback. He’s been working with a quarterbacks coach in Southern California during the off season and the results have been amazing. His awkward, goofy throwing motion is gone. He now steps into his passes and he’s feeling much more comfortable with his new passing ability. And you are dead on right about Nebraska’s receivers being very young. Kenny Bell and Jamal Turner were only freshmen last year and Quincy Enunwa was just a sophomore. Taariq Allen, a 6′ 3″ redshirt freshman is a monster wide receiver and Jordan Westermark, an incoming freshman who set all the wide receiver records in Illinois,(he caught 5 td passes in the state championship game), will also see playing time this fall. Martinez also has Rex Burkhead and both backup rb’s as well as both tight ends. Behind Martinez is all three backup qb’s. The offense is loaded. On defense the Huskers return 3 of 4 defensive linemen, 2 of 3 linebackers and 3 of 4 db’s. Juco db Mo Seisay is a shut down corner and juco lb Zaire Anderson is a head hunter. I agree with you that Nebraska will make more noise this upcoming season. I’m hoping to catch them play Iowa in Kinnick. I think with Iowa’s relatively easy schedule that the Hawks and Huskers could both be at 9-2 going into that game. 

  • Grady

    Michigan is going to be a bear, and they will be have their home game vs. Iowa circled after 3 straight losses…their A.D. has made that clear.  If the Hawks can get to 7-5 (4-4) again this year it will have to be considered a successful season.

  • dipeopleknowme

    Down year for Iowa upcoming.

  • hawk4ever

    Better not be a down year again….

    Not for 4 million a year for our coach.

  • Tisb06

    That’s sounds about right, and there should be no naysayers I think 7 wins with this team will be a real accomplishment.

  • McNutt in Your Face

    Looking at the schedule, great opportunity to open 5-0 given the stretch of home games to start and less challenging opponents,  (toughest will be ISU). We’ll probably lose to 1 team that we “shouldn’t lose to”, like NW, Purdue, Indiana, and pull off one upset against either MSU, PSU, NEB or MICH to get to 8-4.

    In 2013, we should return at least 18 starters, maybe 19 if someone can please beat out Tobin for left gaurd.

  • Hrhino

    I think the new offense with Davis and B Ferentz, will get the Hawks at least 8 wins, CJ the 6’7″ tight end should hit his stride this season, and a returning QB that wants to make his mark on the program.

  • I think Iowa should be around 6 wins this year. 

  • IowaHusker79

    Nebraska’s schedule is very favorable? What flavor of kool aid are you drinking? Nebraska plays one of the most difficult schedules next season. They play Wisconsin, Ohio State, Michigan, Michigan State, Penn State, Iowa and UCLA. How in the heck is that a favorable schedule? 

    • Db1971

      I do not understand that statement either!  maybe a lot of those are home games for the huskers, but that looks to be a pretty tough schedule regardless.

      • IowaHusker79

        Nebraska gets Michigan, Wisconsin and Penn State at home. They travel to Michigan State, UCLA, Iowa and Ohio State. It’s the following year that they have the favorable schedule. Maybe the writer of the column was looking at the 2013 schedule. 

Latest News

  1. Jamal Allen

    May 24 Rob Howe

    Hawkeyes, MI CB Jamal Allen Building Relationship>

  2. B1G Championship Iowa vs Michigan State 2015

    May 22 Jon Miller

    HN Podcast: Best of the B1G Running Backs>

  3. B1G Indy Lucas Oil Stadium

    May 22 David Schwartz

    No ESPN For the Hawkeyes>

  4. Peter Jok

    May 20 Jon Miller

    Jok to Return to Hawkeyes>

  5. Recruiting Update Football

    May 19 Jon Miller

    Iowa Prep Invited to National Nike Event>