Hawk Stock: Receivers in 2011

By HawkeyeGameFilm

It’s time to take a look back at the Iowa passing offense in 2011 as it relates to the receivers, or those who caught passes for the Hawks this year. First lets take a look at the basic numbers:

These numbers tell you about you would have guessed: Marvin McNutt was far and away Iowa’s statistical leader in every significant receiving category. McNutt accounted for more than half of the team’s total TD receptions, 36% of all receptions and 45% of all receiving yards. Among the Tight Ends, C.J. Fiedorowicz tops all statistical categories despite not seeing any targets in five out of the twelve games.

While the overall numbers are good, they don’t tell the full story. Next, let’s take a look at how many targets each WR and TE received, along with Marcus Coker:

*Success % formula: (Catches+Flags drawn)/Total Targets

McNutt saw the most targets and still posted a pretty reasonable success percentage despite the increased workload. Keenan Davis’s success percentage is a little lower than you might expect and Kevonte Martin-Manley’s percentage rivals that of McNutt, but Martin-Manley only had about 40% of the targets. CJF posted a pretty impressive percentage of a very limited number of targets. Generally speaking, TEs are higher percentage targets due to generally running shorter routes, but 80+% is an outstanding success rate. The other two tight ends struggled to get consistent separation on their routes and it shows in their success percentage.

Below is a game by game tracking of targets for the WRs:

Graphing these results game by game gives you a little better idea of how each player’s season went. As the overall numbers indicate, McNutt steadily saw the most targets each week but Keenan Davis’s targets dropped off quite a bit in the middle of the season, even before his ankle injury kept him out of the Minnesota game. The same goes for KMM who peaked during the LA-Monroe game before settling in at a pretty low number of targets as the season came to a close.

The most disappointing number to me is that Staggs only got 4 targets all season. He caught all 4 targets and 3 were against a quality opponent, Michigan State. It definitely seems he could be have been used more often to give the starters a rest and give the defense another look to defend. Overall, it’s a bit concerning that only 3 WRs saw substantial targets and it really makes Iowa easier to prepare for when teams don’t have to worry about defending any sub-package personnel.

Next lets look at the TE/RB targets by game:

Outside of the 3 main WRs, Marcus Coker was the most targeted player. The tight-end group saw their targets really drop toward the middle of the season and in the Northwestern game not only did they not have catch, they didn’t have a single target. Towards the end the season, CJF started to emerge as the most consistent of the tight-ends and he steadily become a bigger part of the offense. Derby was effective at times, especially in the no huddle spread looks and showed the ability to get some separation and make some plays. He wasn’t as effective as an in-line tight-end and at times struggled to get a clean release. Brad Herman had a few bright spots and big catches during the season but struggled to be a consistently effective weapon.

Next up is an area that plagued Iowa all year: Dropped passes

*TCP = Total Catchable passes

The above ‘Drop %’ category is the number of drops divided by total targets. As a team, Iowa dropped 31 passes (several players have been omitted from the above list). That number is alarmingly high and yields an average of about 2.5 drops per game. As far as individual numbers go McNutt and KMM have the best of group for WRs. Dropping almost 10% of passes is still way to high, however. Davis’ drop percentage is a bit higher than you’d like to see for a starter and is an area he’ll need to improve greatly if he wants to have a shot at the next level. Among the tight-ends, CJF has the best numbers and is the leader of that group by a wide margin.

After studying the film and seeing how most of these drops occurred there is no complex underlying reason for the issues with drops. Most of them were just simple problems of trying to run before securing the football or not watching the ball all the way in. Some of the drops came as a result of being in traffic or good defensive plays but far too many of the drops were the uncontested variety.


No matter how you look at the Iowa receiving numbers this year you pretty much reach the same result: Marvin McNutt was consistently effective and everyone else had stretches where they were effective. However, Iowa lacked another consistent threat to help take away some of the pressure from McNutt and it really showed in the last week when Nebraska consistently rolled extra coverage to McNutt. No one else was able to step up and it’s hard to say if it was more on James Vandenberg or the coaching staff. Either way it was painfully obvious that Iowa’s passing game was mostly on McNutt’s shoulders this season.

The good news is that Davis, Martin-Manley and CJF all flashed the kind of ability that leads me to believe they can become more consistent playmakers. The Pitt game was a fine example of the level of play that both KMM and Davis are capable of providing. CJF had great metrics in his limited opportunities this season and clearly has the tools to become a consistent threat and play maker for the offense. The challenge for these three will becoming more consistent in all areas of the game. It will be interesting to see if any of the three step up during the up coming bowl game because they’ll certainly need to step up to fill McNutt’s shoes in 2012.

  • Grady

    Excellent info and analysis is on the mark.  It appeared to me last spring that Staggs had the best hands of WRs (after McNutt), and he didn’t disappoint when given the chance in games…I would have liked to see McNutt, Davis and Staggs on the field more often — Staggs gives a much bigger target than KMM and obviously has better hands.  KMM is probably a little faster, but how often does Iowa throw the long fly pattern?  We are a possession team that needs receivers that can catch the ball, and Staggs fits the bill.  Hope to see him a LOT more next season.

  • Las Vegas Hawk

    I sure would like to see them give CJF a try at WR.  In the past, the big 6’7″ wide receivers from Indiana and Purdue always gave us fits.  I realize he won’t be quite as shifty at 6’7″/270 but, at that size, separation doesn’t mean quite as much.  He appears to have great hands and I would love to see him go across the middle against the smaller DB’s.  He did play WR in high school.

    Las Vegas Hawk 

  • Brad

    The drop percentage by Davis and to a lesser extent, Martin-Manley, were way too high.  If we look back on Iowa’s losses in 2011, all that was needed for them to have an outstanding 10-2 season, was for those two receivers to not drop a few key passes that hit them square in the numbers.

Latest News

  1. B1G Championship Iowa vs Michigan State 2015

    May 31 Jon Miller

    Vegas Win Totals for the Big Ten>

  2. Tyler Peyton

    May 31 Sean Neugent

    Recapping Iowa’s Run to the Big Ten Championship Game>

  3. George Kittle

    May 31 Rob Howe

    Kittle Working on Becoming Next Well-Rounded Tight End at Iowa>

  4. Football WDM

    May 29 Jon Miller

    HN Podcast: Early College Football Point Spreads>

  5. B1G Indy Lucas Oil Stadium Field

    May 29 Jon Miller

    Can ESPN Afford Big Ten Contract?>